I mean, it's milky, creamy, sweet, and has the best indescribable taste. When someone asks, what does caramel taste like? I can only say, Well... it tastes like caramel! You just can't explain it! But now that I think about it, I hope no one asks that!
I made this recipe for a Mexican dinner night I had with friends last week. I made cheese and green chile enchiladas, my friend Irene brought this delicious black bean salad with black beans, avocado, tomatoes. It was so good! Then for dessert, we ate this!
This recipe was a little time consuming, so I made it earlier that day to give it time to chill before we divulged in it. The Dulce de Leche itself was the most time consuming, and then baking the cheesecake took 45 minutes. But while it was time consuming, it was also really easy. Read my directions below before you start so you can time manage properly.
First, before you start anything, set out the cream cheese. Let it soften naturally so your cheesecake filling will be light and fluffy. Try your best to not microwave it to soften it, because this liquifies the cream cheese and the density is heavier.
Second, get that crust in the oven and out of the way. It's super quick and easy. You'll want to focus your time and efforts on the Dulce de Leche. Dulce de Leche, by the way, is basically a Spanish caramel. It is translated to "candy of milk" and is a caramelization process of milk and sugar. This is unlike caramel, which is just a caramelization of sugars only (no milk). Most caramel candies, however, are made of milk and sugar, so this is going to taste similarly to those square caramels you buy from Kraft. You know... those ones you eat about 20 of before you realize you just ate 20 of them.
To make the Dulce de Leche is quite easy, but it needs your constant attention while you're making it, or you might burn it, which is no bueno. You are going to pour your condensed milk into a sauce pan and heat it on medium-low heat for quite a while. Mine took about 20-25 minutes. When you pour the condensed milk in, it will be a nice milky-white color. At the beginning, let it cook and stir occasionally, keeping an eye out for bubbles. If it starts to bubble, stir more frequently. You're going to see it turn into multiple shades of beige and brown before it gets to where you want it, which will look like the color of real caramel (and some say you can also compare it to the color of peanut butter). Once it starts turning to a light beige, you'll need to be stirring it very frequently, watching for the color changes and making sure none cooks to the bottom of the pan. Once it gets to the perfect color of brown, take it off the heat and pour it onto the graham cracker crust. You'll place that aside for about 5 minutes to cool, then place it in the fridge while you make your cream cheese filling.